Casual dining chains were already facing challenges before COVID-19, hurt by the rise of fast-casual competition and increased food costs.
Now, several of the largest restaurant companies in the U.S. are struggling with capacity restrictions on indoor dining and attempting to lure customers with takeout in a bid to avoid financial disaster.
The owners of chains like Outback Steakhouse, Applebee’s and The Cheesecake Factory are on a newly updated list of national restaurants that are facing the highest likelihood of not paying back their debts. When companies default on loans, they are often forced to file for bankruptcy protection, close locations or occasionally liquidate.
One chain, California Pizza Kitchen, already filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection with plans to close some locations. While the nation’s largest publicly traded restaurants face a less than 1 in 5 chance of defaulting in the next year, according to the new report by S&P Global Market Intelligence, they remain in perilous terrain.
Analysts are particularly concerned about the coming winter, which will eliminate outdoor seating options for many restaurants, and the demise of the extra $600 in unemployment benefits that had been available for jobless Americans. Congress is currently debating whether to extend those benefits. “The odds that the largest publicly traded U.S. restaurants will default fell in recent months as states allowed businesses closed by the coronavirus pandemic to reopen,” S&P says in the new report. “But the ongoing financial hits from the virus and uncertainty over whether laid-off consumers will receive expanded unemployment benefits continue to pressure the industry as more companies enter bankruptcy.”
Sales at restaurants and bars fell 26% in June, compared with a year earlier, according to S&P.
But some are faring better than others.
In contrast to sit-down chains, publicly traded fast-food companies are holding up well, in large part due to robust drive-through offerings. For example, McDonald’s has a less than 1 in 200 chance of defaulting, according to S&P.
Dave & Buster’s
This chain, which relies heavily on its reputation as an entertainment venue in addition to its food offerings, has a 16.1% chance of defaulting in the next year, according to S&P. It has the worst credit rating among the nation’s largest restaurant companies.
Outback Steakhouse parent Bloomin’ Brands
This chain, whose famous Bloomin’ Onion item shares a first name with the restaurant’s parent company, faces a 13.2% chance of defaulting.
The company said in a statement on July 24 that comparable restaurant sales at locations that are allowing indoor dining fell 10.7% for the week ended July 19, versus a year earlier.
Known for its all-day breakfast, Denny’s faces an 11.9% chance of defaulting.
Denny’s sales had been improving in June, but its year-over-year sales decline worsened in July, according to the company’s most recent earnings report. Sales for the week ended July 22 were down 41%, compared with a year earlier.
The Cheesecake Factory
Having already failed to make rent payments on time in the spring, The Cheesecake Factory has been facing financial troubles since the start of the crisis. On the other hand, experts say the company’s decision not to pay rent on time might have been a negotiating tactic with landlords.
Applebee’s and IHOP
Dine Brands Global, which owns both chains, has an 11.3% chance of defaulting. The company’s IHOP chain is faring worse than Applebee’s.
BJ’s Restaurants, known for its pizza and beer, has a 9.3% chance of defaulting.